why does one pc run slower than the other?

[Guest Jon Dobson]

I have 3 nearly identical Dell P4 pc's running nearly identical XP operating

systems and software, yet one pc runs much more slowly than the others. For

example, a program I recently wanted to install on all three units installed

somewhat slowly but completely on the 2 faster units, but clogged the slower

unit so much and took so long that I finally abandoned installation. My

question is why does this one pc runs more slowly than the others? RAM is

idential on each unit. The only thing different about the pc's are the hard

drives- the two faster units have 160 GB drives about 60- 70% data filled

and the slower one has a 20 GB drive about 80% full. I checked different

drive specs today and did find differences in onboard drive memory and a few

other factors. Can a different hard drive really make that much difference

in speed even though everything else is identical?

 

Thanks,

Jon

[Guest Patrick Keenan]

Re: why does one pc run slower than the other?

 

"Jon Dobson" <jondobson@mst.net> wrote in message

news:gcjmjk$vmu$1@registered.motzarella.org...

>I have 3 nearly identical Dell P4 pc's running nearly identical XP

>operating systems and software, yet one pc runs much more slowly than the

>others. For example, a program I recently wanted to install on all three

>units installed somewhat slowly but completely on the 2 faster units, but

>clogged the slower unit so much and took so long that I finally abandoned

>installation. My question is why does this one pc runs more slowly than

>the others? RAM is idential on each unit. The only thing different about

>the pc's are the hard drives- the two faster units have 160 GB drives about

>60- 70% data filled and the slower one has a 20 GB drive about 80% full. I

>checked different drive specs today and did find differences in onboard

>drive memory and a few other factors. Can a different hard drive really

>make that much difference in speed even though everything else is

>identical?

>

> Thanks,

> Jon

 

First, a 20 gig drive has to be considerably older than a 160 gig drive. I

haven't seen a new 20 gig drive for sale for a few years now.

 

Yes, many older drives are considerably slower than newer drives, because of

factors like slower transfer rates, slower rotation speeds, and smaller

caches.

 

Also, comparing the free space percentage can be misleading. The 20 gig

drive has around 4 gig free, the 160s have around 50 gig free. That

matters to Windows and installation programs, which often require double the

space of the final installation during the installation.

 

If you're finding that performance is degrading on the 20 gig drive, that

can be a sign that it's near its end of life. In fact it's likely that

it's well beyond it, if you look at the MTBF values (mean time before

failure). If this is the case, replace it.

 

New drives are cheap. Where I am, 160 gig drives are around $50 this week

(they drop regularly). I'd suggest that getting one and just cloning the

20 gig to it is cheaper than the value of the time you'll spend trying to

recover from a failed drive. And yes, you'll probably find it faster.

 

HTH

-pk

[Guest Peter Foldes]

Re: why does one pc run slower than the other?

 

HD are all the same RPM and they are all IDE or mixed with SATA

 

--

Peter

 

Please Reply to Newsgroup for the benefit of others

Requests for assistance by email can not and will not be acknowledged.

 

"Jon Dobson" <jondobson@mst.net> wrote in message news:gcjmjk$vmu$1@registered.motzarella.org...

>I have 3 nearly identical Dell P4 pc's running nearly identical XP operating

> systems and software, yet one pc runs much more slowly than the others. For

> example, a program I recently wanted to install on all three units installed

> somewhat slowly but completely on the 2 faster units, but clogged the slower

> unit so much and took so long that I finally abandoned installation. My

> question is why does this one pc runs more slowly than the others? RAM is

> idential on each unit. The only thing different about the pc's are the hard

> drives- the two faster units have 160 GB drives about 60- 70% data filled

> and the slower one has a 20 GB drive about 80% full. I checked different

> drive specs today and did find differences in onboard drive memory and a few

> other factors. Can a different hard drive really make that much difference

> in speed even though everything else is identical?

>

> Thanks,

> Jon

>

>

[Guest Bob I]

Re: why does one pc run slower than the other?

 

replace that 20 GB drive.

 

Jon Dobson wrote:

> I have 3 nearly identical Dell P4 pc's running nearly identical XP operating

> systems and software, yet one pc runs much more slowly than the others. For

> example, a program I recently wanted to install on all three units installed

> somewhat slowly but completely on the 2 faster units, but clogged the slower

> unit so much and took so long that I finally abandoned installation. My

> question is why does this one pc runs more slowly than the others? RAM is

> idential on each unit. The only thing different about the pc's are the hard

> drives- the two faster units have 160 GB drives about 60- 70% data filled

> and the slower one has a 20 GB drive about 80% full. I checked different

> drive specs today and did find differences in onboard drive memory and a few

> other factors. Can a different hard drive really make that much difference

> in speed even though everything else is identical?

>

> Thanks,

> Jon

>

>